Pele’s Other Garden Deli

Pele's Other Garden Deli – A Popular Spot for Delicious Food and Drinks in Lanai City
Local Expert's Rating:
4 / 5
The Bottom Line:

Pele’s Other Garden Deli serves as a top spot in Lanai City for delicious food and drinks anytime of the day. At this cozy eatery, every day starts with deli-style lunch, and then moves onto the full Italian bistro experience in the evening. They have a full bar as well plus always offer incredibly friendly service to all their valued guests.

- The Local Expert Team

When you want a deli-style lunch or Italian bistro dinner, you can get your fill at Pele’s Other Garden Deli. Set in the heart of Lanai City, this quaint eatery only uses the highest quality ingredients to build big flavors in every bite. They also go all out in creating drinks at their full bar, plus have a wide range of non-alcoholic beverages available as well. Beyond that, they offer a welcoming atmosphere and friendly service that’ll have you feeling right at home in an instant.  

In fact, right as you waltz through the doors of Pele’s Other Garden Deli, their servers will offer warm alohas for all and welcome you to your table of choice. Menus will fall into your hands immediately after followed by ice water to sip as you browse their offerings. Your server will take your drink and appetizer orders right then and there if you’re ready. Otherwise, they will swing back around in a bit to see what you’d like to try.

As you browse the menu at Pele’s Other Garden Deli, don’t hesitate to ask your server for their recommendations. They know all the top dishes on tap and are always happy to direct their guests to the items that’ll speak to them most. Once you put in your order, you might have to wait a little while for your food and drinks to arrive since everything is made from scratch. Fortunately, it’s well worth sticking around for a taste of what’s to come.

Once your food arrives, you’ll undoubtedly notice that it comes in huge portions designed to fill you up right. If you cannot get through it all, just ask for a to-go box. You can even order Chocolate Layer Cake, Crème Brulee Cheesecake, or their other desserts to go once you finish your meal. They will get everything ready to go while you pay your check, so you have leftovers to enjoy after all your Lanai adventures.

Must-try menu items at Pele’s Other Garden Deli include:

With its fresh island ingredients and rich balsamic drizzle, the Bruschetta is a great way to start any meal at Pele’s Other Garden Deli. To create this popular appetizer, they take thick baguette slices, toast them up right, and then top them with fresh tomatoes and homegrown basil. Then, right before serving, they drizzle on a reduced balsamic glaze to finish it off right.

French Dip
A lunchtime favorite, the French Dip brings in people from far and wide, intent on getting a taste of its bold flavors. They create this entrée by cutting open a French roll and filling it with roast beef, provolone, and roasted peppers. The whole lot goes under the broiler until the cheese melts, and then lands in front of you with au jus gravy for dipping.

Chicken Parm
The Chicken Parm is the star of their robust dinner menu, and for good reason. For this entrée, Pele’s Other Garden Deli grills chicken breast to perfection, and then tops it with plenty of marinara and mozzarella cheese. Once the cheese melts under the broiler, the chicken goes over a bed of spaghetti tossed with tomatoes concasse and gets fresh homegrown basil over top.

If you are planning a family reunion, anniversary party, or other special events, take it to the next level with their catering services. You just have to call well ahead to get your event on the schedule, although they can cater for an impromptu birthday party within just 24 hours. When setting up your catering spread, you can get big platters of their top menu items or go with simple boxed lunches instead. Whatever you do, don’t forget to add the delicious desserts from Pele’s Other Garden Deli to the mix to leave your guests feeling wholly impressed.

Insider Tips:
-Although reservations are not required, you’re welcome to book a table for parties up to 10 through the Pele’s Other Garden Deli website.
-Want to leave a personal touch behind? Just bring them an old license plate to display on the wall.
-Local musicians swing by on occasion to keep patrons well-entertained, so be sure to keep your ears perked up for their arrival.