Prison Street Pizza

Prison Street Pizza - A Slice of Jersey Right On the Island
Local Expert's Rating:
4 / 5
The Bottom Line:

If you are hungry for pizza during your visit to Old Lahaina Town in West Maui, then get to Prison Street Pizza where they serve the freshest, most authentic New Jersey Style pies in Maui. Dine-in or carry out and enjoy while taking in the breathtaking beach views. They will also deliver to your hotel. Hours are daily 11 am - 9 pm

- The Local Expert Team

The Islands are full of amazing restaurants that deliciously showcase a variety of cultures and ethnicities. Hawaii is like a melting pot of cuisine goodness and every corner of the island is full of mouthwatering surprises waiting to make your taste buds happy. You might not associate this tropical paradise as a corner of the world to get great pizza but here is one of those surprises! Head over to Prison Street Pizza and enjoy a slice or two of their authentic New Jersey-style pizza. This little place of Italian goodness is easy to find, right on Prison Street, Old Lahaina Town in West Maui. You’ll love this quaint and charming restaurant that was a former plantation-style house turned pizzeria, Maui style. Well, classic New Jersey-style pizza that is. You have to taste for yourself why Prison Street Pizza has the best pizza in Maui.

The owners are dedicated to serving customers pizza truly just like they do in Jersey. All ingredients are fresher than fresh, the pizza dough is made from scratch and tossed in the air to create the most beautiful, crisp pies with loads of your favorite toppings. The irresistible aromas will hit you right when you walk into the door. 

Create your custom-made pizza with the following fresh toppings like:
bell peppers

Or try one of Prison Street Pizza’s tried and true specialty pizzas like:  
Serpico Special
Buffalo or BBQ Chicken
Philly Cheese Steak
The Carnivore
Old World

Pair your pie with a brew from the Kona Brewing Company like their Kona Big Wave or their long board lager, and you will be totally satisfied.

Goat cheese fans will adore The Windmill that is a pesto base covered with ooey-gooey mozzarella cheese, goat cheese, and roasted red peppers. The Grandma’s specialty is a no-brainer that is a decadent blend of Alfredo sauce, chicken breast, spinach, garlic, and mozzarella cheese. If lots and lots of cheese is your thing, ask for the Daily Surfer’s Special. It’s two cheese slices and a soda for $6.99. They also sell beer and White Claw to go for the 21 and older crowd.

Pizza isn’t the only thing on the menu. They have salads, subs, burgers, calzones, appetizers, and delicious homemade desserts. The nutty hula cheesecake is over the top creamy and luscious, the perfect ending to your Prison Street Pizza experience.  

This pizza shop is small and offers limited indoor and outdoor seating. If you’re in a hurry, it’s a great place to grab something delicious to go while you take in the area’s gorgeous views. How funny would it be to take a selfie on the beach at sunset, eating a Jersey-inspired slice from Prison Street Pizza? Now that’s a story to share when you get back home and a memory to cherish forever. There’s nothing quite like enjoying a slice and a cold beverage while strolling hand in hand along Maui’s stunning beaches with someone you love. 

Insider Tip:
Prison Street Pizza offers dine-in, take-out and will deliver straight to your hotel door.  Ask for the Daily Surfer’s Special…two cheese slices and a soda for $6.99. They also sell beer and White Claw to go to the 21 and older crowd.