Teddy’s Bigger Burgers – Lahaina

Teddy's Bigger Burgers – Ultra-Fresh American Fare Made to Order in Lahaina
Local Expert's Rating:
4 / 5
The Bottom Line:

When you simply want to go all out in grubbing on delicious food, don’t miss the chance to stop by Teddy’s Bigger Burgers. A true Lahaina favorite, this cozy eatery creates ultra-fresh American food using quality ingredients and proven techniques. Don’t forget to take your burger to the next level with its specialty styles and awesome toppings.

- The HawaiianIslands.com Local Expert Team

If you work up a huge appetite on your island adventures, look to Teddy’s Bigger Burgers to fill you up to the top. At this Lahaina eatery, they handcraft every burger to order using 100% fresh ground chuck and tons of flavorful toppings. That’s not where their offerings end either. They have many basket combos, salads, and sides that are reason enough to come in all on their own.

You definitely need to get a taste of their signature burger at least once, however, so you know why so many eager patrons hop in line at this joint. While you could go with their Original Burger as written, the real magic is in customizing its build to your preferences. Their specialty styles include Deluxe, Garlic Butter, Bacon Cheese, and Seasoned with garlic, spicy, or ranch. On top of that, they have their ever-popular Umami Style with garlic butter, furikake, and sriracha aioli for a zesty island kick.

In fact, you can use their specialty styles to customize any sandwich on their menu, including their fantastically flavorful Mahi Mahi sandwich. If you prefer to take matters into your own hands, look at the awesome toppings list and get to work dreaming up your perfect meal. Each item on the list is an extra charge, so just keep in mind that the total can add up fast. But sometimes, it’s worth paying the price to act as the master of your own culinary destiny.

With so many incredible culinary creations on tap, it’s no wonder the line goes out the door all day long. Thankfully, the wait goes fast as you explore all the options on the menu and make fast friends with your fellow patrons. Once you get up to the counter, just let them know what you want, and then get settled at the table matching the number they gave you. Your server will whisk your items out to your table as soon as they’re ready.

Their most popular items include:

Original Burger
Available in 1/3, 1/2, and full-pound sizes, the Original Burger always has what it takes to fill up your belly. To create this burger, the chef grills up your 100% fresh ground chunk patty of choice. Once that’s perfectly medium, it lands on a potato bun along with green leaf lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and pickles. Teddy’s Special Sauce completes the flavor experience just right.

Fish & Chips
If you’re in the mood for classic island fare, you cannot go wrong with the Fish & Chips. This basket combo starts with fresh pollack fillets breaded and fried to a light golden brown. Then, they throw them in the basket alongside French fries, tartar sauce, malt vinegar, and lemons. A fountain drink comes with your combo, although you might just want to upgrade to a shake.

Hand-Scooped Shakes
When nothing else will do but ice cream goodness, treat yourself to one of their incredible Hand-Scooped Shakes. You just have to choose between their mini, small, and large sizes, and then let them know what flavor you want. They have vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate, of course, plus peanut butter, pineapple, root beer, and so much more.

In addition to their shakes, fountain drinks, brewed tea, and root beer floats are always available in a variety of sizes. If you’d like an alcoholic beverage with your meal instead, you’ll need to BYOB, for sure. They welcome you to bring whatever beer or wine you’d like to enjoy with your meal – all without charging a corkage fee.

Insider Tips:
-When ordering water, expect to still pay a small fee for the cup.
-If they have to close up shop early, they’ll post an announcement on their Facebook page.
-Prefer to skip the carbs? Ask for a lettuce wrap instead of a bun.