Peggy Sue’s Maui

Peggy Sue's Maui - Classic 50s Diner with Burgers, Hotdogs, Shakes, and More!
The Bottom Line:

Peggy Sue's Maui is a classic 50s diner serving burgers, hotdogs, shakes, and malts. They also have a variety of sandwiches, a few salads, and several vegan burgers. Peggy Sue's Maui uses fresh beef from Maui Cattle Company, and every patty is handmade. 

- The Local Expert Team

Good golly, Miss Molly! Stepping inside Peggy Sue’s Maui is a step back in time. This 50s-style diner is the real deal for those who remember that era. Blue and pink vinyl booths line the windows, and stools face the counter where you can watch fast-order cooks work their magic. 

Memorabilia cover the walls: hula-hoops, pictures of 50s movie icons, posters of vintage products. The blue and pink neon lights add a soft glow to the room and each table has a retro jukebox featuring hits from the 50s-60s. Guests can also choose a song on the larger jukebox that looks like something from the hit TV show Happy Days.

Located in the Azeka Shopping Center in Kihei, Peggy Sue’s Maui offers classic diner food like burgers, hotdogs, shakes, and malts. They use grass-fed beef from Maui Cattle Company for their burgers and Roselani Ice Cream for shakes and malts.  

Aside from burgers and dogs, Peggy Sue’s Maui offers the following on their menu:

Grilled Salmon
Teriyaki Chicken
New York Steak

But let’s be honest. If you’re coming to a diner-like Peggy Sue’s Maui, you’re craving a good burger, hot dog, and milkshakes! All burgers, hotdogs, and sandwiches are served with fries. You may substitute sweet potato fries, onion rings, or a salad for an additional cost. 

Here are some amazing burgers that were popular with guests:

Sh-Boom has two handmade patties, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, and house dressing. 

Good Vibrations
Mushroom lovers will enjoy this burger! Sauteed mushrooms and Swiss cheese crown a handmade patty and come with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, and house dressing. 

Sweet Sixteen
Vegans will love sinking their teeth into this meal! A vegan patty comes with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles. 

Hot dog lovers will want to try one of these favorites:

Seattle Dog
This juicy all-beef hotdog comes with bacon, jalapenos, and onions. 

Ayeee Chihuahua
A classic chili dog! All-beef hotdog with chili, cheese, and onions. 

Be sure to add a milkshake to your meal or for dessert. Peggy Sue’s Maui has two categories for milkshakes: classic and gourmet.

The classic milkshake features Roselani Premium Vanilla Ice-Cream with your choice of syrups like chocolate, blue Hawaii, strawberry, Lilikoi, to name a few. You may add hot fudge, peanut butter, Oreo cookies, bananas, and malt for an additional cost. 

The gourmet milkshake uses Roselani Premium Flavor Ice-Cream. You can customize with any of the treats mentioned above. Here are a few of the gourmet flavors offered:

Banana Mac Crunch
Kona Mud Pie
Aloha Cherry Truffle

While some reviews of the diner and food were mixed, we sided with most guests who had a pleasant dining experience. The interior may be a bit weathered from years of use, but diners loved the 50s diner ambiance. And since most guests praised the burgers, fries, onion rings, and shakes, we think you’ll enjoy stepping back in time when you enter Peggy Sue’s Maui.

Insider Tip:
If you’re looking for a deal, get to Peggy Sue’s Maui for happy hour! From 3-6 PM, guests get 50% off appetizers and 20% off burgers and shakes.