Lahaina Pizza Company

Lahaina Pizza Company - Unique Deep-Dish Pizza And Amazing Harbor Views
Local Expert's Rating:
4.5 / 5
The Bottom Line:

Lahaina Pizza Company is an open-air restaurant that overlooks Lahaina Harbor. Their deep-dish pizza is praiseworthy, and unlike Chicago style, the crust is light, and the pie isn't as thick. They serve ice-cold beer and tropical cocktails featuring fresh juice and ice cream.

- The Local Expert Team

Ages ago, Lahaina Maui used to be the capital of the Hawaiian Kingdom. Today, one could argue that it’s home to some of the best deep-dish pizza!

Lahaina Pizza Company has been serving locals and tourists since 1994. The restaurant is on Maui’s west coast and is perched on the second floor across from the seawall. Diners will love savoring their food and drinks in the open-air restaurant and watching the surfers, boats, whales, and beautiful Hawaiian sunsets. 

Customers rave about the deep-dish pizza but add that it’s nothing like Chicago-style pie. Lahaina Pizza Company’s deep-dish has a light, crisp crust and isn’t as thick as Chicago deep-dish pizza. Diners who dislike Chicago-style pizza commented how they wish Lahaina’s version were available in Chicago!

Pizzas come in small (4-slices), medium (6-slices), and large (8-slices) portions.

Lahaina Pizza Company offers a vegetarian pizza along with these standards:

Shrimp Thermador
Rich and creamy Thermador sauce is topped with fresh mushrooms, spinach, garlic, shrimp, and sundried tomatoes. 

Sweet Pig
Ham and pineapple crown this pie-making it one of the best Hawaiian pizzas you’ll ever have. 

BBQ Chicken
Grilled chicken breast, cilantro, red onions, and special BBQ sauce make this a one-of-a-kind creation.

The Works
As the name implies, this pizza has homemade meatballs, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, and sweet onions.

Cheese & Tomato
This simple classic is an excellent base for adding toppings to create a custom pie!

Lahaina Pizza Company also serves praise-worthy Buffalo Wings. They are crunchy on the outside and juicy on the inside. You may order them hot, medium, or with a mild spice. 

If pizza isn’t calling your name, try one of their house-made sandwiches. They bake the rolls fresh on-site, and each sandwich comes with a side of Capellini Salad. You may select the Sub, Chicken Caesar, BBQ Chicken, Meatball, and Italian Chicken.

Pastas, like ravioli, Fettuccine Alfredo, and lasagna, are also served. Fresh garlic bread comes on the side. 

With the gorgeous view of the bay, many come to savor a cold beverage while enjoying the scenery. Beer lovers will love that their drink will come in a frosty mug. While the beer selection is limited, the choices available will satisfy most beer drinkers. 

For those craving an island cocktail, try one of their Tropitinis. This original creation is a hit with locals and visitors! The drink is shaken, not stirred, to combine fresh island fruit juices and spirits and poured ice-cold into a martini glass. Menu choices are Pacific Sunshine, Blue Bayou, and Fuzzy Navel. 

Another adult beverage that is more like a dessert than a cocktail is their Island Ice Cream Spirits. These drinks feature Roselani Ice Cream, which is made in Maui, to create island-themed cocktails. Some choices are Monkey Pod, Dreamsicle, Pina Colada, and Neapolitan Delight, to list a few. 

Naturally, they serve traditional cocktails that are island favorites. Lahaina Pizza Company is famous for its Mai Tai. They are the only location that adds Grand Marnier to the drink. It’s a huge hit with locals! 

Lahaina Pizza Company is family-friendly and makes smoothies with fresh island fruit that your kids will love. They may choose either chocolate, strawberry, or banana and pineapple.

We think you’ll love eating, drinking with family and friends at the Lahaina Pizza Company. Aside from delicious food and frosty drinks, you’ll savor the harbor view and the stunning sunsets, too.

Insider Tip:
Lunch specials like individual pizzas and a daily special are available seven days a week from 11 AM-4 PM.