Warren & Annabelle’s Magic!

Warren & Annabelle’s Magic: Intimate Theater With Top-Notch Entertainment and Food
Local Expert's Rating:
4 / 5
The Bottom Line:

Warren & Annabelle’s Magic is a top-notch dinner-theater that features world-class magicians. The 78-seat theater provides comfortable seating and has visitors close enough to interact with the performer. Dinner and the show will take about 3.5 hours. Patrons have the option of seeing the show without dinner, too. Guests must be 21, and reservations are required.

- The HawaiianIslands.com Local Expert Team

So you’re in Maui, and you’re looking for a thrilling evening out on the town. But you’re tired of the trendy bars and nightspots and movie theaters. You want something invigorating, exciting, something that will blow your mind.

It sounds like you need an evening at Warren & Annabelle’s Magic!

When we heard about Warren & Annabelle’s Magic, our first thought was that it would be in a nasty, smoke-filled venue with has-been acts from Atlantic City. The humor would be crass, the magic subpar, and the food tasteless.

What we discovered was the exact opposite. Warren & Annabelle’s Magic is in a small theater in Lahaina. It offers top-notch magicians and delicious food and drinks. Reservations are required, and guests must be 21 or older.

Let’s start with the venue. The 78-seat theater is stylish and gives guests up-close encounters with the performers. Guests in the front row are close enough to the stage that the magician will often use their items for sleight-of-hand tricks. And if you’re not near the front, the theater-style seating gives every visitor a prime viewing angle. 

Regarding the aforementioned “has-been acts,” the talent at Warren & Annabelle’s Magic have impressive resumes. We’ll dispense with listing the accolades, but suffice to say, these magicians are well-respected in their industry and worldwide. Founding member Warren Gibson may even be on the docket to entertain. His genteel Southern charm, sharp wit, and sleight-of-hand tricks will have you dazzled and laughing all night.

Many patrons prefer arriving early for dinner in Annabelle’s Parlor, which is warm, inviting, and comfortable. The entire evening is a little over 3/5 hours. If time and cost are a factor, you may purchase tickets for the show only, which is a nice feature.  

The menu has a wide selection of filling appetizers, desserts, and drinks. Here are some popular options:

Tangy Crab Cakes
The crab cakes are cooked to a golden brown and come with a sweet chili plum sauce atop a bed of mixed greens. 

Tropical Kalua Pork Wrap
A quesadilla is piled high with Hawaiian Kalua pork mixed with tropical mango salsa and served on mixed greens. 

Ravioli with Sauce de Jour
Pasta filled with vegetarian stuffing and served with sauce and greens. Inquire about the Chef’s “flavor du jour.”

Chocolate Pots de Creme
If you love chocolate, you’ll love this dessert! Rich, chocolatey custard that’s smooth and delicious with every bite.

Visitors to Warren & Annabelle’s Magic rave about the stellar entertainment, delicious food, and wonderful night of fun. Reservations are required, and guests must be 21 years of age. If you’re looking for a fun-filled evening with laughter, superb magic, and tasty food and drinks, we believe you should visit Warren & Annabelle’s Magic. 

Insider Tips:
If you’re considering getting dinner, look into The Royal Flush Package. Guests receive better pricing than ordering a la carte. The price includes admission to the show, gourmet appetizers, dessert, cocktails (or non-alcoholic drinks), and gratuity.